Voice

How to Draft by Speaking: Why You Turn On the Mic Before Facing the Blank Page

On days when choosing the first sentence wears you out, start with your voice instead of your hands. This guide walks through drafting by speaking: pick a listener, answer three questions out loud all the way through, and only then revise.

Why your hands stall and your voice does not

A common reason drafts stall at the keyboard is that the writer and the editor live in the same body. You write a sentence, dislike it, delete it, write it again and delete it again. The screen is left with a blinking cursor.

Speaking works differently. Words already out of your mouth cannot be deleted, so when something comes out wrong you rephrase it and keep going. The editor has no room to step in, and the story reaches its end. Drafting by voice borrows that property. The fixing happens later, all at once.

What the research shows, and what it does not

In a study published in 2018 by researchers at Stanford University and others, participants transcribed short phrases on a phone [1]. Speech was 2.93 times faster than the keyboard in English (153 vs. 52 words per minute) and 2.87 times faster in Mandarin (123 vs. 43 WPM). Speech also produced fewer errors that had to be corrected during entry (5.30% vs. 11.22%).

The task, though, was copying given phrases, not composing your own thoughts from scratch. And speech left slightly more errors in the final text (1.30% vs. 0.79%). Speaking fills the page faster, but set aside time afterwards to hunt for wrong words.

Pick one listener

Talking into thin air scatters your words. Before you start, choose one person to tell this to: the colleague next to you, yourself a year ago, a friend new to the subject. Once there is a person, where to begin and which words to unpack decide themselves.

This works even better out loud than on the page. Most of us are more used to explaining things to people by talking than by writing, so picturing a listener brings out the order of explanation we already know.

Lay the path with three questions

With a listener in mind, write down three questions they would ask: why you are telling them this, what changes because of it, what they should do now. Then switch on the microphone once per question and answer it. The questions act as a table of contents, so you do not get lost even when you talk for a while.

Write the questions as sentences. Single words such as background or problem leave you stuck again once you start talking.

Only a topic written down
Topic: next month's application(Switch on the mic and say whatever comes)
Questions written down
Listener: the colleague who joined this week1. Why are we rewriting the application?2. What changes?3. What should I do this week?

Talk all the way to the end

  • When you get stuck, leave a spoken marker such as example needed here or check the number, and move on. The moment you go looking it up, the draft stops.
  • If you say something wrong, correct yourself and keep going. Even if Wednesday, no, Thursday ends up on the page, you keep only the last version when you tidy up.
  • Stop once per question. Talking in parts leaves you less lost when you revise than one long take.
  • You do not need to watch the screen while you talk. Words that are not final yet show only on the bar under the editor, so you can look up and talk.

Revise once you have said it all

Revise in three passes. First, skim to the end once and check that the story stands up. Next, select what you dictated and tidy it to clear away fillers and repeats. Tidying does not change your meaning or order, so moving the conclusion up or choosing paragraphs to cut is your job.

Finally, check names, numbers, dates and technical terms against the source. As the study above found, dictated text tends to keep wrong words, and tidying never guesses at a word that looks misheard. The order of the clean-up is covered in detail in the guide on cleaning up dictation.

What to start out loud, and what not to

Kind of writingStarting out loudBetter by hand
Meeting notes, retrospectivesYou capture it while the memory is freshDates and owners of what was decided
Blog drafts, essaysA draft with your voice in it comes quicklyThe title and the first paragraph
Work email repliesYou settle the order of what to say firstRecipients, attachments, numbers
Writing heavy on tables, code or quotesSpeak only the outline and the explanationsTable cells, code and the quotes themselves

References

  • [1] Ruan, S., Wobbrock, J. O., Liou, K., Ng, A., & Landay, J. A. (2018). Comparing Speech and Keyboard Text Entry for Short Messages in Two Languages on Touchscreen Phones. Proceedings of the ACM on Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies, 1(4), 1-23. doi:10.1145/3161187

Frequently asked questions

Doesn't a spoken draft run long?

Speech tends to come out longer than writing for the same content. So once you are done, tidy it to remove fillers and repeats, and pick the meeting notes or weekly report format to condense it into lists. The other formats do not shorten anything, so choose the paragraphs to cut yourself.

What if there are people around?

You can speak quietly, but a soft voice or a noisy room can make the transcription less accurate. Where you need to stay quiet, type just the three questions and save the talking for when you are alone.

Which language should I speak in?

The editor listens in the language of the page you are on. On the English pages it writes down English, so to dictate in Korean, open the editor on the Korean pages.

Next guide: Cleaning Up Dictation, in Five Passes From Transcript to Usable Writing →